Sunday, September 20, 2015

Two Million Dogs Farmed for Meat: Can the practice be stopped?

These dogs were supposed to be somebody's lunch.

Dogs rescued from meat trade
These are two of 29 dogs who arrived in San Diego last Thursday
Confined in tiny cages at a South Korean meat farm, they were supposed to be made into Gaejang-guk, a spicy stew that many traditionalists still believe will balance body heat during the summer months.
57 dogs rescued by Humane Society International and Change for Animals Foundation from a dog meat farm in Hongseong, South Korea, arrive in San Francisco
Dogs at a meat farm in Hongseong, South Korea
Humane Society International and others paid the owner to start farming chili peppers instead of dogs.
57 dogs rescued by Humane Society International and Change for Animals Foundation from a dog meat farm in Hongseong, South Korea, arrive in San Francisco
The owner of the meat farm signs a contract with the Humane Society to close his facility for  good.
Twenty-nine rescued dogs arrived in San Diego last Thursday, and will soon be put up for adoption.
57 dogs rescued by Humane Society International and Change for Animals Foundation from a dog meat farm in Hongseong, South Korea, arrive in San Francisco
Arriving at the San Francisco Airpoit
The Humane Society International is on a mission to wipe out the dog meat trade. and are working with animal rights activists throughout southern Asia to rescue animals scheduled for slaughter. Since August of 2014, they've rescued more than 8,000 dogs.
yulin dog meat festival
Dogs on their way to market at the Yulin Dog Meat Festival
Dog meat has been on the menu for at least 2000 years in much of Asia, Especially in summer, since according to local superstition, it warms you up and helps to ward off the chill of the coming winter. The meat is thought to be tastier if the dog suffered a particularly painful and frightening death--which happens to an estimated 10,000 dogs during the annual summer soltice dog meat festival
yulin dog meat festival
A Protester at the 2014 Dog Meat Festival
But for the last few years, the festival has drawn increasing numbers of protesters. 

It's mostly the older people in Asia who still eat dog meat. Most younger Asians do not, and many share the Western aversion to eating dogs. 

More and more Asian celebrities are campaigning against dog farms and dog meat festivals..
Fan BingBing, the 4th Highest Paid Actress in the world, has spoken out against the dog meat festivals.

l
Many Asians differentiate between pet dogs (purebreds) and "meat" dogs. But this perception is beginning to change. Keeping pets, banned for many years in China, is now popular. And most people don't like eating their pets.

Authorities in Yulin Province deny the existence of Chinese dog farms. They insist that all dogs eaten at the festival were abducted from the streets. (How is this better? )

It's certainly not safer. People have died because they ate meat from rabid dogs.. The risk is understood in Vietnam, where workers in dog slaughterhouses are routinely vaccinated for rabies. 

As more people understand the risks, as more people come to love their pet dogs, as the pressure from social media mounts, and as the last generation of die-hard dog-eaters passes into history, I believe that the dog-eating days of summer will come to an end.

Tuesday, August 11, 2015

Why Does the Bluebell Railway Station have a stuffed dog on Display? And Why Does it Bother Me?


London Jack at the Bluebell Railway
In the 19th century, British railway workers left a lot of orphans. During the 1830's & 1840's, while the railroad was being built, a railway worker's job was said to be more dangerous than that of a soldier fighting the Battle of Waterloo.

Between 1875 and 1900, thirteen thousand railway workers died in boiler explosions and other accidents, leaving their wives and children without a wage-earner.
TrainWreck6
Aftermath of a Boiler Explosion
The workers' families had no safety net. Compensation for the risk of injury or death was presumed to be included in the men's wages.

Support for orphaned children fell to the church, and the newly established railway worker's unions, with the help of dogs who walked around the stations and boarded the trains, soliciting donations.
A different
A  Dog Named Railway Jack in 1934
There was a whole line of dogs named London Jack, but there were also Carlo, Laddie, Station Jim, Handsome Boy Prince, Nellie, Nigger, Sandy, Kim, and numerous others whose names are less well known.

One of the early collection dogs was Brighton Bob, a railway dog of the 1860's. In Bob's day, the dogs took donations in their mouths, which they would then give to their handlers.

Except for Bob.

He, being an enterprising soul, preferred to spend his take buying biscuits from the local bakery. At least until a journalist caught him at it.
'Handsome Boy Prince'; a charity dog which once worked at East Croydon station (image: Old Southeronians Association).
"Handsome Boy Prince" who collected at East Croyden Station
In the late 19th century, the dogs started carrying collection boxes on their backs--thus providing the opportunity for a (literal) shakedown. In 1896, thieves grabbed an Irish Terrier named Tim, who was working in Paddington Station. They held him upside-down by his feet and shook him until the contents of his collection box fell into a suitcase they had brought for the purpose. Tim at least had the satisfaction of biting one of the malefactors when they released him.

Successful dogs got medals: silver for collecting £100, gold for £500. The dog on display at the Bluebell Railway Station in Sussex, London Jack V, collected over £4000 between 1923 and 1930, a remarkable sum in those days. He is covered with medals, both silver and gold.
Five Southampton West Jack medals
Silver Medals Awarded to Southhampton West Jack
Each represents £100 collected
Jack, like many other collection dogs, wasn't allowed to retire just because he died. Instead he was stuffed and put on display in the expectation that his earthly remains would continue to support the orphanage, which they did--at least until 1998, when Jack's takings were used to pay for his restoration.
London Jack - before restoration
This is what Jack looked like when the Bluebell Railway got him in 1979.
When the taxidermist began work, he discovered that Jack had not been a a golden retriever, as everyone thought. His fur had apparently bleached during his years on display. He has now been dyed black--his original color, and the money he collects once again goes to the orphans.

Here are some of the other dogs whose stuffed remains still collect for the railway orphans:
Laddie, who died in 1956, at the London Railway Museum
London Jack, who worked at Paddington Station 1894-1900
Station Jim, who collected at Slough Station from 1894-1896
The stuffed dogs bother me a bit. If human philanthropists were stuffed and put on display after their deaths, I think most people would see it as a violation of their humanity.

I feel the same visceral reaction to a stuffed dog (or bear or moose, or lion) that I would to a stuffed human being.

There is an appalling (to me) museum in a small Sussex town that features cute animals such as bunnies and kittens all dressed up as schoolchildren, guests at a tea party, or getting married.
British taxidermist Walter Potter has a new book that includes a carefully curated selection of photos of his finest works, like rabbits at school, pictured here
One of the displays at the museum in Bramber
The museum was a huge hit in the Victorian era, and maybe still is--but I couldn't bear to look at the displays, especially since I couldn't help suspecting that many of those cute little animals died for no better purpose than to showcase the taxidermist's artistic talent.

The railway dogs died of natural causes, and since they were dead, they probably didn't mind being stuffed, but I do mind just a little bit.

http://www.bluebell-railway-museum.co.uk/images/a015.pdf
http://www.nrm.org.uk/OurCollection/UsingTheRailway/CollectionItem.aspx?objid=1990-7629&pageNo=313
http://trainboard.com/highball/index.php?threads/railway-collecting-dog-laddie-from-the-national-railway-museum-in-york.43620/
http://osamemories.yolasite.com/our-faithful-friends.php
http://virtualvictorian.blogspot.com/2009/10/station-jim-and-london-jack.html
http://blackcablondon.net/tag/railway-collection-dogs/
https://books.google.com/books?
https://mrsdaffodildigresses.wordpress.com/2015/01/07/the-railway-dogs-who-collect-for-charity-1910/
conditions of workers who built the railroads